9 min read

How to govern a disputed land: a conversation about Nagorno Karabakh

Hello! Cristina here. This week, there was no shortage of international news, with the Quad's meeting in Washington, the United Nations General Assembly in New York, and the German elections kicking off TODAY.

Meanwhile, U.S. Secretary of State Antony Blinken met with Turkish Foreign Minister Mevlüt Çavuşoğlu on the sidelines of the U.N. General Assembly, and they had "a relatively long conversation about the Caucasus – Armenia, Azerbaijan, Nagorno-Karabakh," according to Senior State Department officials.

That brings me to today's conversation. Once upon a time in London (really, it was 2011), Artak Beglaryan and I were both completing master's degrees at the University College London's School of Slavonic and East European Studies.

Today, Artak is the Minister of State of Nagorno Karabak, a disputed territory in the Caucasus to which Azerbaijan and Armenia lay claim. Nagorno Karabakh is officially part of Azerbaijan, but most of the population is ethnic Armenian and wants to govern itself.

The conflict over Nagorno-Karabakh has been mostly frozen since the mid-1990s, but renewed fighting broke out in 2020. The violence lasted for six weeks, leaving over 5,000 people dead and tens of thousands displaced.

If you want to know more about the history of the conflict and the recent dispute over prisoners of war, you can read my article for VICE here. But Artak and I spoke over the phone recently about what Nagorno Karabakh needs now and what it's like to run the government in a tiny disputed territory.

You can read our conversation below.

Disclaimer: The content of these conversations does not reflect the opinions of Lazo Letters. This is one interpretation of a very complex situation, and I'm aware that many other analysts, experts, and people on the ground will have their own understanding of these events.

You can pitch me ideas for who or what to feature in this newsletter or send story tips: c.maza@protonmail.com or cmaza@nationaljournal.com.
Upgrade to a premium subscription by Clicking Here.

Cristina: Congratulations on your new position. Can you tell me about the job and what your plans are for the role?

Artak: Right now, I am State Minister, which is something like the Vice President because I am the second executive after the President. I am also coordinating the activities of several ministries, including the Ministry of Social and Labor Affairs, education, culture, science, and justice. And most humanitarian issues are also under my coordination. That's all.

Cristina: That is an extremely broad role. How are you juggling all of that?

Artak: Most of the Ministers work independently, but I am coordinating their work. I'm not always jumping into the details. I'm giving them broad directions and setting goals. I am also monitoring how they are doing and carrying out the tasks the President and I have given them.

I have a staff of over 40 employees, and each ministry has even bigger teams. Many have more than 150 workers.

Cristina: What are your main goals going into this new role? What do you hope to accomplish?  

Artak: My most significant task is to deal with the humanitarian issues from the war. My first goal is to overcome the emergency situation because over 27% of our population is internally displaced persons (IDP).

That's a huge number for us. It's a population of over 40,000 people, which isn't huge nominally. But for our country it's enormous.

We need to tackle the housing problem. That's the number one humanitarian issue.

Right now, we are building houses and providing temporary housing. But still, over 2/3rds of our IDPs are in Armenia because we don't have enough temporary housing solutions in Nagorno Karabakh.

Secondly, we also have social problems, labor problems, and income problems. We need to solve these problems for IDPs but also for other socially vulnerable groups.

We give cash support to people, but we are also working on restoring the economy. We have some development project plans, and in 18 months, we will launch a few projects to develop the economy.

Still, we don't have tangible international support. We get help from the Armenian government and the Armenian diaspora, but it's not a lot for us.

The second goal is to implement long-term reforms to overcome systemic institutional problems.

We've had a crisis, and a crisis is a chance for us to implement institutional reforms in education, in social affairs, and in the healthcare system.

Cristina: What kind of support does Armenia give you?

Artak: They give us a lot of humanitarian and financial support. This year, the government of Armenia provided us with over $180 million in humanitarian support. That's quite a large sum for us.

They also gave over 80% of our annual budget, which is over $160 million.

Without Armenia, we cannot live here.

The Armenian diaspora also sent a few hundred million dollars, around $250 million to support housing projects and other primary humanitarian needs.  

Cristina: How have things changed since the outbreak of violence in 2020? And what is the security situation like now?

Artak: Things are getting better. The situation is much more stable than it was immediately after the war. Immediately after the war, it was winter, and people didn't have housing. Now the situation is somewhat stable.

We've launched large projects to build new buildings, communities, and settlements. At the end of this year, we're going to finish the first construction projects, and by the beginning of 2022, we expect the housing situation to be much better.

The security situation is also stable. The most problematic security situation was the constant uncertainty after the war. Now people see that they can plan their lives and have a future here.

But of course, it's a fragile situation. Azerbaijan and Turkey are pretty aggressive, and they want to destabilize the security situation. In Nagorno Karabakh and Armenia, they want to jeopardize the Russian peacekeepers' security guarantees.

They sometimes make statements about the temporary status of the Russian peacekeepers to make people fear that they can't have a future here. They say they will take all of Nagorno Karabakh with force, and the international community doesn't react. Sometimes they violate the ceasefire with minor violations. It's a way to pressure people to leave.

We currently have a population of 120,000 people. Before the war we had a population of 135,000. That means that over 85% of the population has returned, which is not so bad.

Cristina: How do you assess the role of the Russian peacekeepers?

Artak: Quite positively. They are the number one factor for having peace here. There is no other international force keeping peace in Nagorno Karabakh.

Also, our army is weak after the war. We experienced significant losses, both human losses and a loss of arms. Azerbaijan and Turkey are both against us, and they have a lot of sophisticated weaponry. Given this, we can't protect our homeland alone.

Russian peacekeepers are pretty essential for us.

Unfortunately, there is no other international effort. There is no humanitarian or international human rights organization present.

We have three co-chairs for mediation efforts, Russia, the U.S., and France, under the OSCE Minsk Group. But even those co-chairs haven't visited since the war. We want a peace dialogue and negotiations under the OSCE, but Azerbaijan blocks all of the efforts.

The United Nations organizations should visit Nagorno Karabakh. We are open to that.

But we haven't gotten much international humanitarian aid because Azerbaijan blocks the access of humanitarian organizations and politicizes all humanitarian efforts.

The United States Agency for International Development (USAID) gives money to the Halo Trust for demining, but nothing else.

We have many needs because of the war and long-term humanitarian needs, like access to water resources, education, and economic development. Over 50% of our kids are deprived of pre-school education. Over 40% of our whole population has difficulty accessing clean drinking water. We need hundreds of millions of dollars just for our basic needs.

International human rights law says that, regardless of status, no area should be denied humanitarian support. Only the International Committee of the Red Cross is here.

That's why I say the humanitarian community has failed to protect our human rights.


What I'm writing:

• I wrote about the Biden administration's decision to prioritize its relationship with Australia at the expense of its relationship with Europe. The main takeaways are: Australia is now central to the Biden administration's foreign policy goals; Europe is no longer Washington's most important ally, and U.S. lawmakers from both parties support the new AUKUS security pact.

• I wrote about the Afghan diversity visa lottery winners who are seeing their hopes of escaping the Taliban fade as the State Department struggles to handle their cases. If the cases aren’t resolved by Thursday, the diversity-visa selectees risk losing the opportunity to emigrate. Many told me their lives are at risk if they stay in Afghanistan.

What I'm reading:

• Two Republican campaign operatives were charged in a new federal indictment with funneling $25,000 from a Russian national into former President Trump's 2016 campaign. The indictment alleges that Jesse Benton and Doug Wead worked together to accept $100,000 from an unidentified Russian national to land the foreigner a meeting with then-candidate Trump.

• The U.S. is flying Haitians camped in a Texas border town back to their country and blocking others from crossing the U.S. border from Mexico, the Associated Press reports. Haiti has asked the U.S. for a humanitarian moratorium on deportations because the country is in crisis and doesn't have anywhere to house people. Multiple planeloads of Haitians continue to leave the U.S. every day.

• The U.S. is preparing almost to double the number of Haitians deported from Texas, raising concerns that the return of thousands of migrants will exacerbate the current humanitarian crisis in Haiti, the Washington Post reports. Homeland Security Secretary Alejandro Mayorkas told the Senate there are no plans to halt deportations.

• Photos and video showing Border Patrol agents on horseback chasing, grabbing, and perhaps whipping migrants led the Department for Homeland Security (DHS) to investigate the footage. DHS does not tolerate the abuse of migrants in our custody, the department said in a Tweet.

• Former Catalan President Carles Puigdemont, now a member of the European Parliament, was arrested in Italy by order of a Spanish court, according to his lawyer. Politico Europe has the report.

• Russia's Ghostwriter hacker group – which has ties to Russian intelligence – is aiming at the German elections, Politico Europe reports.

• The U.K.'s counterterrorism police charged a third person in the 2018 attempted assassination of former Russian spy Sergei Skripal. The charges are against a senior Russian military intelligence officer who entered the U.K. two days before Skripal and his daughter were poisoned in the English town of Salisbury, the New York Times reports.

• The Biden administration blacklisted a cryptocurrency exchange, SUEX OTC, to combat ransomware. The Russian-owned cryptocurrency exchange was blacklisted for allegedly helping launder ransomware payments, the Wall Street Journal reports.

• Lithuania's defense ministry said that consumers should avoid buying Chinese mobiles and throw away the ones they have after a government report found the devices had built-in censorship capabilities, Reuters reports.

• A top aide to Ukrainian President Volodymyr Zelenskiy was shot at while driving in his car outside Kyiv in an assassination attempt. Serhiy Shefir was unharmed, but his driver was shot and wounded, Irina Venediktova, Ukraine's prosecutor general, said in a statement on Facebook that accompanied a photo of the vehicle.

• Ukrainian lawmakers approved a draft bill to limit the influence of oligarchs.

Ukraine began joint military exercises with the U.S. and other NATO troops, with 4,000 Ukrainian troops and 2,000 foreigners participating in the RAPID TRIDENT - 2021 drill, a Ukrainian defense ministry spokesperson said.

• The European Union summoned Georgia's envoy to Brussels, Vakhtang Makharoblishvili after leaked files alleged the country's security agency spied on the E.U.'s diplomats and others, Radio Free Europe reports.

• Authorities discovered the bodies of four migrants on the border between Belarus and Poland. Their cause of death is still unclear, Spiegel reports.

• France's partners in the European Union agreed to put the country's dispute with the U.S., Australia, and the U.K. over AUKUS and submarines at the top of the bloc's agenda in coming months, including at an E.U. summit next month, the Associated Press reports. But France and the U.S. appear to have since made amends.  

• France's Armed Forces Minister traveled to Mali last weekend to pressure the military junta there to end discussions about bringing Russian mercenaries to the country, Reuters reports.

• A New York Times report on the Panjshir region of Afghanistan revealed claims of massacres and ethnic cleansing by the Taliban. The report also found very few signs of active resistance in the area.

• Nearly three metric tons of heroin from Afghanistan, with a street value of $2.7 billion, were seized from Mundra Port in the western Indian state of Gujarat in a major bust, the Guardian reports.

• The Sudanese government said that people linked to the deposed regime of longtime President Omar al-Bashir attempted a coup this week but have been brought under control, Al Jazeera reports.

• The Washington Post has a report on a Syrian detention camp rocked by an estimated 70 killings blamed on Islamic State women, "who take advantage of the fragile security to enforce their strictures and settle scores."


Upgrade to a premium subscription by Clicking Here.

As always, you can contact me with questions, complaints, corrections, or for any reason at all: c.maza@protonmail.com. And if you like this newsletter, please share it on social media or with a friend.